In January 1909, newspapers printed hundreds of claimed Jersey Devil encounters in a single week. In 1868 a Utah paper ran a lake serpent story that its own author later called a "wonderful first-class lie." Ten American monsters, none of them Bigfoot, each with a pin on the Phantom-Finder.com map.
The Flatwoods monster has more names than most West Virginia towns have stoplights: the Braxton County monster, Braxie, the Phantom of Flatwoods. It is one of ten American creatures on this list, and not one of them is Bigfoot.
Cryptids, in the working definition, are animals or other beings whose present existence is disputed or unsubstantiated by science. The ten here are a mixed bag. A winged, hoofed devil in the New Jersey pines. A frog-faced figure along an Ohio river. A werewolf-like canine on the back roads of Wisconsin. A serpent in a lake on the Utah and Idaho border. A coyote in Texas that was blamed for livestock attacks and ended up with its own name. Wings, scales, fur and fins, and none of it the big hairy biped that already has its own list in Top 10 Bigfoot Sightings.
Five of the ten were investigated on MonsterQuest, the History series that premiered in 2007. Others got Lost Tapes, Haunted Highway, Expedition X and similar shows. Where a map card and the episode record disagree on a season or episode number, the entry follows the record.
Every title below links to its spot on the Phantom-Finder.com map, so you can read the story and look at the ground it came from.
Two things decided the order: cultural footprint first, quality of the record second. There is no scoring math.
The Jersey Devil leads because the legend is old, the name is everywhere, and a hockey team carries it. The Flatwoods monster is second because it has a dated 1952 event and a long reach into pop culture. Bear Lake follows with a nineteenth-century newspaper trail, and Loveland with police reports. Bray Road has a reporter-driven record from the 1980s and 1990s and two films. Elmendorf sits mid-list because it has a carcass and an answer, which is a better record than fame. Whitehall is a well-told local case with police witnesses and a small reach. The Alaska and Columbia River Gorge entries rest mostly on one TV episode each. Texarkana closes the list as a short coda.
During the week of January 16 to 23, 1909, newspapers published hundreds of claimed encounters with the Jersey Devil, and the fear reportedly led some schools to close and workers to remain at home. That is the loudest chapter of a legend that is much older and far less tidy.
The story goes that a woman named Leeds had twelve children and cursed her thirteenth with the words "Let the child be the devil!" One summary puts that in 1735, though the legend is dated variously, so treat the year as part of the folklore. Before the early 1900s the creature was often called the Leeds Devil. Descriptions are fairly consistent: a flying biped with hooves, leathery bat-like wings, a horse- or goat-like head, and a scream.
The setting does its share of the work. The New Jersey Pine Barrens, also called the Pinelands or the Pines, is the largest remaining example of the Atlantic coastal pine barrens, stretching across more than seven counties. In 1978 Congress designated 1.1 million acres of it as the Pinelands National Reserve, the nation's first. It is a lot of forest for a legend to hide in. The creature is also the namesake of New Jersey's NHL team, which is a rare honor for a monster.
MonsterQuest aired "Devils in New Jersey" as Season 3, Episode 4 on History, with a TVmaze air date of February 25, 2009. Destination Truth took it up in "The Jersey Devil / The Yeren," Season 3, Episode 12 on Syfy, first aired March 31, 2010. As the title shows, that episode shares its hour with a second creature, the Yeren.
📍 See the Pine Barrens on the map
At 7:15 p.m. on September 12, 1952, brothers Edward and Fred May and their friend Tommy Hyer reported a bright object crossing the sky above Flatwoods and landing on a farmer's property. They told their mother, and a group went up the hill to look, including a West Virginia National Guardsman, Eugene Lemon.
What happened next depends on who is telling it. Lemon said he aimed a flashlight and briefly saw a tall "man-like figure with a round, red face surrounded by a pointed, hood-like shape." Gray Barker, writing in Fate Magazine, gave its height as about 10 feet. Witnesses also reported a pungent mist, and some later reported nausea. The sheriff and a deputy searched the site and "saw, heard and smelled nothing." West Virginia Public Broadcasting notes that the telling has varied over the years, and that the monster's look keeps changing.
The usual skeptical answer, from investigator Joe Nickell in 2000, is a meteor, an aircraft beacon and a startled barn owl. Flatwoods itself is a small town in Braxton County, about a mile from exit 67 of Interstate 79, with 264 residents in the 2020 census. The legend reached further than the town did: a 2019 episode of Project Blue Book was based on it, and the welcome sign reads "Home of the Green Monster."
MonsterQuest's "Lizard Monster" (Season 4, Episode 7, History, March 10, 2010) is the Flatwoods episode, despite a title that sounds like something else. Its listing describes a humanlike beast with reptilian skin that has been terrorizing Flatwoods since it was first sighted in 1952.
📍 See Flatwoods on the mapIn 1868 the Deseret News ran Joseph C. Rich's report of "a strange, serpent-like creature inhabiting the waters of Bear Lake," which he called "this water devil." Twenty-six years later Rich described the story as a "wonderful first-class lie." That is an unusual thing to find at the root of a monster legend, and it is the most important fact about this one.
The tale did not stop. An 1881 Deseret Evening News account described "a large undulating body, with about 30 ft of exposed surface" about three miles off. Other reports gave a length of at least 40 feet, perhaps 50, and a body with legs about 18 inches long, spikes along the spine, and a head compared to a cow, otter, crocodile or walrus. Rich's original article also credited the idea to a tradition he attributed to Native people. Given his later admission, we are not treating that as independent lore.
Bear Lake is a natural freshwater lake on the Idaho and Utah border, with a maximum depth of 200 feet. That is deep enough for people to imagine almost anything beneath it, and it has done exactly that for more than 150 years.
Lost Tapes, a dramatized first-person series, aired "Bear Lake Monster" as Season 2, Episode 9 on Animal Planet on November 17, 2009. It follows five friends celebrating a birthday at the lake, and the survivors report what happened. It is fiction built on the legend, not a record of an event.
📍 See Bear Lake on the mapAt 1:00 a.m. on March 3, 1972, Loveland police officer Ray Shockey was driving on Riverside Drive near the Totes boot factory when an animal ran across the road in his headlights. He described leathery skin, a length of 3 to 4 feet, and a weight of 50 to 75 pounds. It "crouched like a frog," then stood up, climbed the guardrail and went back toward the river.
The older story is pure folklore. In 1955, a businessman or salesman reportedly saw three figures, 3 to 4 feet tall, standing on their hind legs, with leathery skin and froglike faces. In some tellings one held a wand that threw sparks.
Two weeks after Shockey's report, a second officer, Mark Matthews, said he shot an animal in the same area. By his account it was "a large iguana about 3 or 3.5 feet long," missing its tail, and Shockey confirmed it was the animal he had seen. So the two 1972 reports do not stand as independent sightings: by the second officer's account, the animal ended up an iguana. In 2016, reports of a couple playing Pokémon Go near the river who claimed to see a froglike being on its hind legs revived the story. The Little Miami River runs 111 miles through five Ohio counties, and Loveland made the frog its city mascot in 2023.
The episodes listed for this location, Lost Tapes "Loveland Frog" and Monsters and Mysteries in America "Loveland Frogman," do not appear in the Wikipedia episode lists for either series, so we are not describing them here.
📍 See Loveland on the mapWitnesses often describe it as between 6 and 7 feet tall, with a humanoid body covered in fur, a wolf-like head, and large glowing red or orange eyes. Some say it moves on all fours, others on two legs. That mismatch is part of the record.
Reports from rural roads near Elkhorn, Wisconsin, built up through the 1980s and 1990s, and the local Walworth County Week assigned reporter Linda Godfrey to the story. She began as a skeptic but came to believe many witnesses were sincere. Her articles became The Beast of Bray Road: Tailing Wisconsin's Werewolf, published in 2003 by Prairie Oak Press. Elkhorn is the county seat of Walworth County. One account dates the first sighting to 1936, at a school near Jefferson, Wisconsin, and that is a claim, not a documented event.
Proposed explanations are ordinary: gray wolves, large dogs such as Great Pyrenees or Newfoundlands, or black bears with mange, along with hoaxes and mass hysteria. The legend has since drawn two films, the 2005 horror feature The Beast of Bray Road from The Asylum and the 2018 documentary The Bray Road Beast, released on October 5, 2018.
In Search of Monsters aired "The Beast of Bray Road" as Season 1, Episode 8 on Travel Channel on May 22, 2019, per TVmaze, which describes a cunning beast that terrorizes a Wisconsin village. Haunted Highway paired it with Tonopah Mine in Season 2, Episode 3 on Syfy on December 10, 2013, with Devin Marble and Jael de Pardo hunting it in the snowy Wisconsin woods.
📍 See the Bray Road Beast on the mapIn August 2004, a rancher named Devin McAnally shot an animal in Elmendorf, Texas, that had been blamed for several attacks on livestock. It weighed about twenty pounds, with a severe overbite and unusual blue, hairless skin.
Experts at the San Antonio Zoo could not conclusively identify it, though from the skull they speculated it was a Mexican Hairless Dog. A DNA assay at the University of California, Davis, later found a coyote with demodectic or sarcoptic mange, not originally hairless. Two similar carcasses found elsewhere in Texas also turned out to be coyotes with severe mange. Some locals had linked the animal to the chupacabra legend, and others to an escaped lab experiment. Those are stories. The carcass and the lab result are the record.
Elmendorf is a city mainly in Bexar County, about 17 miles southeast of downtown San Antonio. The beast that unsettled it weighed roughly what a bag of dog food does.
MonsterQuest aired "Chupacabra" as Season 2, Episode 8 on History on July 23, 2008. History's listing says the chupacabra was first sighted in 1995 and blamed for multiple farm animal deaths. A review at Reactor describes the episode's main event as the examination of the bones of the animal killed in Elmendorf, and notes that the Texas specimens were nearly or completely hairless.
📍 See Elmendorf on the mapOn August 24, 1976, three teenagers driving on Abair Road near Whitehall, New York, reported a figure at the roadside around 9:00 p.m. By their account it stood 7 to 8 feet tall, with dark, matted fur and red eyes that shone in the headlights. They said it gave a high-pitched squeal and ran toward the car, and they drove off and reported it to the Whitehall police. That version comes from a Bigfoot-sighting roundup site that cites the witnesses' later testimony, not from a 1976 newspaper, so read it as what the witnesses said.
Police were part of the story too. The same roundup says a Whitehall police officer reported a tall, hairy, red-eyed creature near the Skene Valley Country Club, and that other officers and some family members later reported encounters too. Over the next week, according to that account, residents including hunters and farmers added reports of loud whoops and 16-inch footprints with a 5-foot stride. The town split, with some calling it pranks or misidentification.
Whitehall is a town in Washington County, New York, and the case is known there as the Monster of Whitehall.
MonsterQuest aired "Bigfoot in New York" as Season 2, Episode 12 on History on August 20, 2008. History's listing reads: "The Monster of Whitehall is a huge, unidentified creature seen in NY in 1976."
📍 See Whitehall on the mapThe listing for this episode gives three things: whitewater rapids, "a frigid Alaskan lake," and a legendary beast. No listing we found names the lake, so we are not going to guess one. The photo here is an example of an Alaskan lake, not the one in the episode.
Alaska has a lake monster story of its own at Lake Iliamna, the largest body of fresh water in the state, and around 1979 or 1980 the Anchorage Daily News offered $100,000 for tangible evidence of it. No listing ties this episode to that lake, so treat the two as separate until a source says otherwise. What the episode summary does say is that the beast is now the target of serious scientific inquiry.
That is a thin record for a ranking, which is why the entry sits near the bottom. A title, a season number and a short summary do not make a case file.
Expedition X aired "Alaskan Lake Monster" as Season 5, Episode 5 on Discovery, with a TVmaze air date of June 22, 2022. The summary has Phil and Jess searching whitewater rapids and a frigid Alaskan lake, and says that, armed with new eyewitness accounts and advanced underwater robotics, the team takes a deep dive for answers. The listing does not say what they found.
📍 See the Alaskan lake on the mapThe episode title does most of the work: "Atomic Ape Cat." The TVmaze summary has Phil and Heather hunting a giant ape-faced black cat by a WWII nuclear facility.
The setting is real and large. The Columbia River Gorge is a canyon of the Columbia River in the Pacific Northwest, up to 4,000 feet deep and over eighty miles long, and it forms the boundary between Washington to the north and Oregon to the south. Across those 80 miles the scenery shifts from temperate rain forest in the west to dry grassland in the east. In fall 2017 the Eagle Creek Fire burned in the gorge for three months, consuming almost 50,000 acres.
The nuclear part is where we stop. The listings we found call it a WWII nuclear facility without naming it, so we cannot say where it sits relative to the gorge, and we make no claims about what the episode says it hid. The map card calls the facility WWII-era in one place and ties the story to Cold War secrets in another, and the listings support only the first.
Expedition X aired "Atomic Ape Cat" as Season 11, Episode 2 on Discovery, with a TVmaze air date of January 14, 2026.
📍 See the Columbia River Gorge on the mapTexarkana was founded in 1873 on the junction of two railroads, and State Line Avenue follows the Texas-Arkansas line through much of it. The post office even straddles the border. Texarkana, Texas, sits in Bowie County, and Texarkana, Arkansas, is the county seat of Miller County across the line. This entry is the Texas side of that line, where the map card places reports of hairy, bipedal creatures in the marshes. The Arkansas side of the story is told in Beast of the Bayou.
MonsterQuest aired "Swamp Stalker" as Season 3, Episode 3 on History on February 18, 2009. History's listing places a legendary beast in the marshy swamp land of Texarkana, and TheTVDB's listing says it hunted the residents of a small Arkansas town.
📍 See Texarkana on the mapDescriptions are fairly consistent. The Jersey Devil is usually described as a flying biped with hooves, leathery bat-like wings, a horse- or goat-like head, and a scream. Before the early 1900s it was often called the Leeds Devil. All of this is folklore, and the 1735 date some summaries give for its origin is one variant among several.
Some locals linked it to the chupacabra legend, but the lab result says otherwise. A rancher shot the animal in Elmendorf, Texas, in August 2004. A DNA assay at the University of California, Davis, found a coyote with demodectic or sarcoptic mange, not originally hairless. Two similar carcasses found elsewhere in Texas were also coyotes with severe mange.
There is no proof of one. The legend starts with Joseph C. Rich's 1868 report in the Deseret News of "a strange, serpent-like creature," and twenty-six years later Rich called the story a "wonderful first-class lie." Later accounts, such as an 1881 report of a large undulating body, kept it going, and the Lost Tapes episode about it is fiction built on the legend.
All ten entries have a pin on the Phantom-Finder.com map, and each pin opens its own card there. The ten pins are free to browse, and the stories above are the ones the records and the episode listings support.
Sources: Wikipedia (Jersey Devil, New Jersey Pine Barrens, Flatwoods monster, Flatwoods West Virginia, Bear Lake monster, Bear Lake, Loveland frog, Little Miami River, Beast of Bray Road, Elkhorn Wisconsin, Elmendorf Beast, Whitehall New York, Columbia River Gorge, Texarkana metropolitan area, Cryptid), West Virginia Public Broadcasting, History.com, Rotten Tomatoes, TVmaze episode records, Reactor, and the Lost Tapes episode list. Image credits: Pine Barrens photo by andrew leahey, CC BY-SA 2.0, Commons file page; Flatwoods photo by Don Woods, CC BY-SA 4.0, Commons file page; Bear Lake photo by Hermann Luyken, CC0, Commons file page; Loveland photo by Minh Nguyen (User:Mxn), CC BY-SA 4.0, Commons file page; Bray Road photo by Corey Coyle, CC BY 3.0, Commons file page; Elmendorf photo by Michael Barera, CC BY-SA 4.0, Commons file page; Whitehall photo by Alee7457, CC BY-SA 3.0, Commons file page; Alaska photo by Diego Delso, CC BY-SA 4.0, Commons file page; Columbia River Gorge photo by Mattsjc, CC BY 4.0, Commons file page; Texarkana photo by Michael Barera, CC BY-SA 4.0, Commons file page; Header image: Bear Lake from US 89 at Garden City, Utah, photo by Hermann Luyken, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.